About
Welcome to Caruso's Italian Restaurant & Pizza Shop, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Lancaster, PA, at 3545 Marietta Ave. This inviting establishment is your go-to destination for authentic Italian flavors and hearty American classics, all expertly crafted to satisfy your cravings.
At Caruso's, the menu is a delightful exploration of Italian cuisine. From their all-day offerings of calzones and strombolis to a selection of pasta dinners that pay homage to classic Italian flavors, each dish is prepared with care and quality ingredients. Signature items like the Chicken Steak Boli, Cheese Calzone, and the rich, savory Bolognese Sauce will transport your taste buds straight to Italy.
What truly sets Caruso's apart is not just the delicious food, but the value and customer experience. As one satisfied customer, Brooke Williams, shared, the catering services provided full trays of pasta and salad for an affordable price, impressing everyone at her baby shower. The generous portions promise that you will leave satisfied, as Frank Schultz attests: "Come hungry—the portions are good!"
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it perfect for a family dinner or a casual outing with friends. Even when busy, diners have noted the attentive and friendly service. Whether it's a casual meal or a special occasion, the experience is designed to be enjoyable for all.
Don't just take our word for it. Customers rave about the delightful flavors and the fantastic value at Caruso's. Derek Nolt enjoyed a Pulled Pork BBQ Boli that was "hot, fresh, and tasted great"—a testament to the quality that Caruso's consistently delivers. The cheese steak sandwiches have also been highlighted as some of the best around, surpassing many local competitors, according to Elvin Ufo.
For those who appreciate authentic Italian cuisine with a twist of American flair, Caruso's Italian Restaurant & Pizza Shop is a must-visit. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or sharing a family-style meal, you'll find comfort and joy in every bite.
For inquiries, you can reach them at +1 717-285-3885. Be sure to stop by and experience the mouthwatering offerings of Caruso's—where every meal is crafted with passion and tradition.
“ Perfect pizza, perfect ordering process, perfect pick-up!! We online ordered at Willow Street Caruso's a cheese pizza with ground beef and another cheese with tomato and black olives. The pizzas were so good that we went to eat dinner at the Silver Spring location. Yummy. I had shrimp with a delicious red sauce (I can't remember what it was called). ”
“ I have always loved this carusos! The food is great! I just used them for my baby shower. We did full trays of pasta and salad. You can’t beat the price for how much food we got. I was getting quoted 300-600.0 at other places for catering for only 25 people. Carusos by far had the best pricing & everyone loved the food. Customer service was great also! ”
“ Come hungry portions are good. You get your monies worth of food, and it's delicious. Very friendly environment. Waitress was very well attended and very sociable. ”
“ This was a medium pulled pork bbq boli. It was hot, fresh and tasted great and I am sure the leftovers will be great later. The restaurant was busy and had a bit of a wait but it was still worth it. ”
“ The cheese steak was 100 times better then Bobby Bay's, it came out nice and steaming hot with a lot of meat, The hoagie was also delicious again better then Bobby Bay's it was huge, I am glad that I found this place because Bobby Bay's sucks big time, the food there is the worst I have ever tasted. ”
“ Excellent place with even better people. The food tasted great and was very fresh. HOT! The server was very attentive and friendly....and even though they were short handed that evening, she was always on top of it. After stopping back a few days later on 1/2/24 the (I believe it was the owner Alex) chatted with me. He was great!!! Not only did he treat me over the top; from what I witnessed there, he really cares about the employees and his coworkers and it shows. The WARM brownie rocks! Ha. Thanks again! ”
“ Caruso’s is my “go to” lunch or dinner spot when I find myself west of my home in East Hempfield! I love Caruso’s. Their pizza is great and their Italian dinners are huge, whether you eat in or take out. The freshly baked bread is delicious! The staff is friendly, courteous & efficient. I stop there every chance I get! ”
“ 10/10 always! Service is always the friendliest around and I've been eating here for over a decade and have yet to leave disappointed. ”